None other than Mary Jo Foley (she’s covered MS and computing for 30 years) has written to update her readers about Stardock’s Start 10:
“Start10 will allow users to add a classic or enhanced Start menu to Windows 10, and to access both desktop and Modern/Metro-Style apps from the Start menu. Start10 will enabled unified search for apps, settings and files and also provide a skinnable Start button.
With the Start-menuless Windows 8, the need for a Start menu replacement seemed fairly clear-cut. Many users wanted and needed a familiar, easy way to navigate the OS. But why introduce an alternative Start menu for an operating system that will have one?
The new Windows 10 Start menu isn't the same as the current Windows 10 one, which includes tiles and omits jump lists and context menus, Stardock CEO Brad Wardell noted on Twitter.
Wardell told Neowin.net that he sees Start10 as a total replacement for Microsoft's Windows 10 Start menu, not a complement to it. Wardell also said he sees the market for Start10 as being desktop, not tablet, users.
I've already seen several people on Twitter claiming Start10 is unnecessary.
Some think Stardock should wait to see the final version of the Start menu in Windows 10 before rolling out a replacement menu.
Wardell's response (via Neowin):
"I've yet to meet a power user who is happy with the current implementation of the Start menu on Windows 10. A desktop OS is not about launching apps. I can do that on a tablet or an iPad. A desktop OS is about managing your 'stuff' -- your data. We really need Microsoft to understand this distinction. What Start10 is designed to solve is the issue of ensuring that it is always easy and convenient to get to your stuff." – Neowin
You can read more about Start 10 here: https://www.stardock.com/products/start10/ , here in frogboy’s forum post https://forums.wincustomize.com/461881/page/1/#3525874 and in Island Dog’s article about Start 10 here: https://www.wincustomize.com/article/461878/ .
It’s available now to Object Desktop subscribers…so…subscribe now if you haven’t already!
Sources and links:
http://www.zdnet.com/article/stardock-to-deliver-a-windows-10-start-menu-replacement/#
http://www.neowin.net/news/brad-wardell-talks-start10-the-follow-up-to-the-popular-start8-start-menu-app
https://www.stardock.com/products/start10/
https://forums.wincustomize.com/461881/page/1/#3525874
https://www.wincustomize.com/article/461878/