Ramblings of an old Doc

“Google's search engine has started warning users that they've installed certain malware. "Your computer appears to be infected," a banner will proclaim across the top of every Google search whenever the malware is detected. Clicking a link in the banner leads to instructions on how to find an appropriate anti-virus program to remove the software.” – arstechnica

This is the warning (image from Neowin.net):

 

Actually, the link leads to a Google search page which lists many antivirals which may or may not do the job, and which may or may not be “real” antivirals.

Google isn’t doing an “instantaneous” scan of your hard disk. It’s simply detecting whether your browser has been routed through proxies controlled by the distributors and creators of the malware used to hijack your browser through these proxies which are generally transparent to users. While this is a minor privacy breach, the motives are pure. The malware which was installed before hand, most likely by the fake antivirus modifies the user's hosts file so that domain names can be looked up without having to use a DNS server.

So Google is doing a good deed, right?  Yes and no.

Letting folks know this is theoretically a good thing, but one of the first signs you’ve arrived at a phishing site is a notification that “Your PC is Infected!” which leads to a phony scan and malware installation. That’s how the “MacShield” and “WindowsProtector” (came with variants and various names) operated.

While a minor privacy breach, the detection came from a good motive:

“Damian Menscher, who works for Google as a security engineer said, "we hope that by taking steps to notify users whose traffic is coming through these proxies, we can help them update their antivirus software and remove the infections.”" – Neowin.net

I do think that the search page the browser is led to by clicking the link should have been well screened for phishing/malware links, though.

Also, the criminals are, I’m sure already changing their proxies.


Comments
on Jul 23, 2011

Why can't these companies just leave people alone and let us fend for ourselves like intelligent human beings?

All you have to do is run a top notch anti-viral software (just one folks, not 2,3,4,5,6,7, etc.), know what the heck you are doing by NOT clicking on links you are not sure of, and if you get an email from someone you don't know DELETE it! Even if it is from someone you know and the email contains information you know they would never have any reason send, DELETE it too!

Simple rules to follow. Google, you are a search engine, stay that way and stay out of our lives.

on Jul 23, 2011

I think it's somewhat of a good Ideal just not the way they did it.. 

this to me will help a lot of (Don't know what the hell they are doing on a computer) People

now if they could take it a little farther or the browser makers

and add some type of scanner to scan your browser for bad HBO's Toolbar, plug-in  (<--- So when you click on or use one of them)

the scanner see's it's bad ... and gives you an out.. to remove it .... or stay dumb and continue using it.. 

I know my Older sister sure could use it .. her toolbar is 6 to 8 inches  like 8 to 18 lines

 but she would (( stay dumb and continue using it )) it's fact cause she had me put them all back when I removed over 3,0000 of just (mywebsearch) yes you read it right Three Thousand Plus

 

 

on Jul 23, 2011

DisturbedComputer
I removed over 3,0000 of just (mywebsearch) yes you read it right Three Thousand Plus

on Jul 23, 2011

DrJBHL
I removed over 3,0000 of just (mywebsearch) yes you read it right Three Thousand Plus

 

oops 3,000  

on Jul 23, 2011

Letting folks know this is theoretically a good thing, but one of the first signs you’ve arrived at a phishing site is a notification that “Your PC is Infected!” which leads to a phony scan and malware installation.

That is exactly what I thought when I looked at the image up there - Looks just like one of those bogus notices.  If I see a notice like that I'm going to believe it's most likely bogus.

on Jul 23, 2011

It would be better if it told the user exactly what it has detected (that they are being routed through a malware proxy) and that they should look into anti-virus/anti-malware software (and not give a link).

on Jul 23, 2011

Gwenio1, your thoughts mirrored mine.

on Jul 23, 2011

LightStar
Why can't these companies just leave people alone and let us fend for ourselves like intelligent human beings?
For we´re Not ! We are Sheep. (I´m an exception of course)

on Jul 25, 2011

I pay good money for proper AV protection.  I'll be damned if I'll be happy with some ubiquitous search engine usurping LEGITIMATE commercial protection by being so presumptuous as to think they can do a better job AND subsequently link me to whom-ever pays them the most to do so.

on Jul 25, 2011

Ah, the joys of the so called 'free market.' 

on Jul 25, 2011

Letting folks know this is theoretically a good thing, but one of the first signs you’ve arrived at a phishing site is a notification that “Your PC is Infected!” which leads to a phony scan and malware installation.

And the second sign is when your browser does not browse!  I guess Google will catch some wimpy ones.  It is the though that counts, right?

on Jul 25, 2011

I think they had good intentions, just not well thought through.

There are 'sniffers' which can be installed as browser extensions, however - if your pc is infected, I can't guarantee those would work...

on Jul 26, 2011

I'm of the opinion that this is intended more as a revenue raiser and not so much a community service.... therefore I would not trust it, and less so because Google is behind it.