Ramblings of an old Doc

 

 
 

On Monday, AT&T will begin restricting more than 16 million broadband users based on the amount of data they use in a month.

This means that a majority of U.S. broadband users will now be subject to limits on how much they can do online. You can do more, but it’ll cost you – and how!

“AT&T's new limits - 150 GB for DSL subscribers and 250 GB for UVerse users (a mix of fiber and DSL) - come as users are increasingly turning to online video such as Hulu and Netflix on-demand streaming service instead of paying for cable.” – Ryan Single http://www.wired.com/

AT&T joins Comcast and numerous small ISPs in putting a price on a fixed amount of internet usage.  Your “Unlimited” plans have gone the way of “dial up” which prevented the growth of the Internet to what it is today.

Now they’ve got you by the short and curlies, let’s see you give anything up. Canada just went through this. Stephen Harper (a fine man and Canada’s PM) put a stop to it there, but at a price: Netflix’s quality has dropped severely.

“Comcast's limit, put into place after it got caught secretly throttling peer-to-peer traffic, is 250 GB - which the company says less than 99 percent of users hit. AT&T plans to charge users an extra $10 per month if they cross the cap, a fee that recurs for each 50 GBs a user goes over the cap. And while 150 GB and 250 GB per month might seem like a lot, if you have a household with kids or roommates, it's not too difficult to approach those limits using today's services, even without heavy BitTorrent usage.” – Ibid

For those not accustomed to calculating their bandwidth usage, video streaming and online gaming use much more bandwidth than web browsing or e-mailing. For instance, Netflix ranges from .3 GB per hour to 1.0 for normal resolution movies and up to 2.3 GB per hour for HD content.

“It should noted that U.S. limits are far from the world's worst: Canada's recently imposed restrictions prompted Netflix to give customers there a choice of lower-quality streams to keep their usage down, because users are charged up to $5 per GB that they exceed their cap. Caps are also worse in Australia.” - Ibid

Hello! Reality check ISP’s:

“It's not about the cost of data – bandwidth costs are extremely low and keep falling. Time Warner Cable brought in $1.13 billion in revenue from broadband customers in the first three months of 2011, while spending only $36 million for bandwidth - a mere 3 percent of the revenue. Time Warner Cable doesn't currently impose bandwidth caps or metering on its customers - though they have reserved the right to do so - after the company's disastrous trial of absurdly low limits in 2009 sparked an immediate backlash from customers and from D.C. politicians.”

What’s it really about? It’s about competition. The ISP’s want to sell you movies, games and video. So do Netflix and other third parties like Hulu. The ISP’s would rather have you spending money on their video services. In other words, they want all the marbles.

So what’s the problem? Instead of laying more pipe, the ISP’s want profit for nothing and to squeeze out the competition by causing the quality of the video to drop seriously if they want to stay in the market. Once that happens, guess what the ISP’s ads will say? “Why pay more for quality like this?”.

As new users are added, the problem will only worsen, and you’ll pay more for even less.

The only solution is to lay more pipe. But that would keep things as they are and the ISP’s would get to Utility Company rates instead of reaping the HUGE profits they do from their fiefdoms. As if Utilities are cheap.

“Indeed, the question of who gets to write the rules about the internet's pipes is the major bone of contention in the net neutrality debate, both for terrestrial and mobile data networks. When the new net neutrality rules go into effect, ISPs won't be able to block their online video competition, but there's no rule against doing that with bandwidth caps or tiered usage pricing.” – Ibid

What sucks the most? It’s about meeting Wall Street’s profit growth expectations, not in making things affordable and reasonable. Screw that (and us).

This greed is also detrimental to getting to and keeping first place in economic, scientific, technological, educational and every other growth you can name.

It throttles the “natural resources” needed to build and encourage the growth. For that reason, if not for your own pocketbook you should be on your feet screaming. BTW – more pipe means more jobs locally to lay the pipe.

This just goes to show, yet again, what's good for Wall Street often doesn't translate into what's good for Main Street.

Source: http://www.wired.com/


Comments (Page 6)
8 PagesFirst 4 5 6 7 8 
on May 05, 2011

I spent a little time reading up in the AT&T forums -- apparently this is AT&T's way of cracking down on people running businesses out of their home and using residential net service.  The official AT&T moderators, when asked "how can you impose this cap, and then have the 'my usage' feature broken for U-Verse customers" answered "don't worry, when you go over your limit, we'll notify you." 


[insert phony German Terminator accent here]  Dey know becoz dey haf 'insiders'.

 

on May 05, 2011

Doc, I'm the only one in my household who doesn't have a tattoo, but after seeing the one you posted, I think I want one--but I want mine to have Ceiling Cat peaking out from my back.

on May 05, 2011

And the NC anti-community broadband just passed with a vetoproof majority.  Ugh.

 

Gotta love bought and paid for state legislatures.

 

on May 06, 2011

DrJBHL
[insert phony German Terminator accent here]  Dey know becoz dey haf 'insiders'.

 

Wrong Movie - you should have used Total recall.

 

on May 06, 2011

DrJBHL
[insert phony German Terminator accent here] Dey know becoz dey haf 'insiders'.

He's Austrian.....

You ain't heard nuthin' 'til you've been joking around with Gerhard Berger and he's come out with the the phrase "I'll be baaaaack" ....

[...and if you're wondering who Gerhard Berger is....he drives cars]...

on May 06, 2011

They always mistake our people for Germans. Sometimes it is for our benefit (as most think Hitler was a German)

on May 06, 2011

TobiWahn_Kenobi
They always mistake our people for Germans. Sometimes it is for our benefit (as most think Hitler was a German)

Quick! We must judge Tobi by the actions of one man! To arms!

on May 08, 2011

Oatesy03
Quick! We must judge Tobi by the actions of one man! To arms!

<highjack topic>

Well if it only was one man.Sadly they were many and still are...

But thats not to say every living german and austrian should be to blame for what has happened 70 years ago (but some seem to think differently)

</highjack topic>

on May 08, 2011

I've had "Capping" on "My" Internet for some time now up here in Canada. Montreal to be more specific. I have a fixed rate and I pay for overages. The thing is, since it started, they keep sending notices that they have Upped the cap. My ISP is a cable/My Internet. It went up this past April. I believe my Cap is 50 Gbs. It was somewhere around 20 when it started. I've seen my bill go up $80 or $90 $CDN a month, many times before they raised it to 50 Gb

I can only sympathize with all of you, It's a drag and is not right.

Doc I don't think we had a choice but to join, people today don't even know the names of their neighbors.

Great article.

 

Did you like my references to My internet?

 

 

 

on May 08, 2011

This is the sort of thing that has  to be regulated by government, as there is no free market for internet due to the entry costs.

 

Internet service is a utility not a luxury.

on May 09, 2011

Alstein
This is the sort of thing that has to be regulated by government, as there is no free market for internet due to the entry costs.

One day the greed will end.... cos ordinary folk won't have any f**king money left.

on May 10, 2011

check out the economist "Wolff"   He has a pretty good explanation;   www.rdwolff.com  

on May 11, 2011

I read the opening statement by rdwolff. It proves what I said once before. Corporate America i.e. Big Business (mega bucks and all that good shit) runs, as in controls, this country. Why do you think us poor bastards on the bottom line pay through the nose while those up top collect, sit back and laugh their asses off all the way to the bank. Capital-ISM is a good thing.....no. Revolution is coming and the fat ass pigs will find themselves on the spit. Laugh my ass off i will if I'm still here to see it.

on May 11, 2011

His "solutions" would require courage, not greed and self interest sooo no chance.

on May 11, 2011

Wolff's "solutions" are no more than a political diatribe.  Corporations are taxed (the debate is whether to tax them less to attract more since we are in competition with countries that do so), and price gouging is against the law (albeit an impotent law due to the inviolate law of supply and demand).

8 PagesFirst 4 5 6 7 8